Labels Really Don’t Matter Anymore

Reading Time – 4 minutes

One of the new things in the Collapsing West over the last 15 years is that most labels in the English language are becoming incredibly inaccurate, and thus useless.

It’s bizarre and fascinating to watch.

For example, the word “racist.”

Before about 15 years ago, if someone called you a racist, that was a big deal. You probably were a racist, at least in most cases. Even if you weren’t a racist, you were in huge trouble. You’d probably get fired, or worse, and everyone would hate you.

But then the left went full-on insane and started calling everyone a racist. (Even I have been called a racist, or at least have implied to be so, even though my son is black and my last girlfriend was Asian.)

After 15 years of psycho left-wingers screaming at everyone and calling everyone a racist, today, if someone publicly calls someone else a “racist,” nothing happens and no one cares.

The left has over-used the term and has thus destroyed it.

This is unfortunate because racism is a real thing and real racists (what few there are in the left-wing Western world) should be called out. But now they can’t because the term “racist” has been destroyed by the left.

The right did this with the term “libertarian.”

Before about 15 years ago, “libertarian” meant you were for abolishing government completely (anarcho-capitalists) or you were for reducing government down to near-microscopic levels (minarchists, like me).

A libertarian NEVER voted for a Republican no matter how compelling he was because Republicans always make government bigger, which is the opposite of what libertarians wanted, and libertarians knew this.

But the right, after losing the culture war around 2011, went completely insane, embraced Trump, and suddenly the internet was flooded with people who used to be libertarian but quickly converted to big government nationalists, espousing the opposite views they just had a few years prior (Alex Jones, Vox Day, Stefan Molyneux, and many others) or guys who still call themselves “libertarians,” yet get ecstatically happy whenever Trump wins an election (Dave Smith, Peter Schiff, and many others) even though Trump is one of the biggest big-government presidents in human history, and they know it.

So now, the word “libertarian” means nothing. It just means another big-government Trump supporter.

It’s gotten so bad that every time I identify myself politically, I have to say that I’m a “minarchist libertarian” because if I say “libertarian” people will assume I’m a typical right-wing Trump worshipper who doesn’t mind at all when Trump increases government spending by trillions of dollars like he did before the pandemic hit.

Indeed, as of 2024, the terms “right” and “left” don’t even mean anything anymore as I already analyzed here.

Left-wing or right-wing views are not how Americans voted in 2024. Instead, they voted on whether or not they liked or hated Trump.

Trump is pro-abortion. He said numerous times that he would never ban abortion, yet left-wing pro-abortion people voted against him, saying he would ban abortion.

And the right-wing religious anti-abortion types loved voting for Trump saying he would ban abortion.

The “left” loved that Dick Cheney supported Kamala Harris and the “right” loved that Trump said he wanted “free” government health care for people just like Bernie Sanders.

So even the terms “left” and “right” don’t really mean anything anymore. The more accurate term is “pro-Trump” or “anti-Trump,” both of whom are largely left-wing in their fiscal views and have a lot of overlap in their cultural views (when is the last time someone on the “right” proclaimed that weed should be illegal?).

Before 2020, the term “vaccine” meant a shot you took that prevented you from getting or transferring a particular disease forever.  If you got a chickenpox vaccine, that means you’d never get chickenpox for the rest of your life.

But since the pandemic, the medical community has forever changed the definition of “vaccine” into a shot you take where you’ll still get the disease just as easily and still transmit it to others just as easily. WTF?

The “vaccine” just prevents you from dying when you get sick. It doesn’t actually “vaccinate” you against anything.

But just a few years ago in 2019, that wasn’t the definition of a “vaccine” and any doctor would kick you out of his office if you said so.

This label even extends to my own life. I’m starting to feel strange identifying as an “American.”

  • I don’t live in America.
  • I will never move back to America.
  • I don’t spend any time in America with very rare exceptions (2025 is the first year I have no prescheduled dates to be in the USA).
  • I don’t have any assets in America (other than a few checking accounts).
  • I don’t like going to America (I like to be around happy people, and that’s not America).
  • I disagree with just about everything the American government does, both on the “left” and the “right,” and have for most of my life.
  • I no longer like or agree with what the culture of America is today in 2025.
  • 97% of everyone I spend time with in a typical month of my life is not American.
  • 97% of everyone I spend time with treats America as a strange, distant land they’ve never been to and can’t relate to.
  • I rarely hear anyone speak with an American accent.
  • I vastly prefer my two homes in Dubai and Paraguay over America, and this opinion strengthens every year as these two countries get better and as America gets worse.

That all being said,

  • I hold an American passport (for the moment, hint, hint).
  • I obviously look American (huge, pale white man with dark hair, blue eyes, and American features).
  • I’m still completely in love with American culture pre-2007 or so (though I love non-American cultures as well).
  • As unhealthy as it is, I love American food and probably always will.
  • My outlooks and attitudes regarding life are very 1980s America (success, capitalism, individualism, wealth, masculinity as a good thing, thinking big, lifting weights, women with big boobs, etc).
  • I speak in a very American style (loud, blunt, strong American accent).

So am I an American?

I don’t know.

These days I feel like either I’m not an American and am instead a citizen of the world, or I’m an “outdated” 1980s-style American that doesn’t really exist in American culture anymore.

Honestly, and I never thought I’d say this, I relate to more non-American people who have moved here in Dubai (success-minded business hustle culture guys) than I do modern-day Americans.

I have a feeling that in a few years, I’ll say the same thing about relating more to the happy, friendly people in Paraguay than today’s angry, jaded, depressed, drug-addicted, suicidal Americans.

Even during conversations with my American parents and siblings (all of whom live in the USA), I feel like I can’t relate to them anymore.

Listening to my left-wing mom talking about how the Christian Right is destroying America, or my left-wing dad talk about how all American whites are racist by default, or my Trump-supporter brother who is absolutely orgasmic that Trump is going to wave a magic wand and magically fix everything in the USA…

I mean, I love these people, but when they talk they sound to me like aliens from another planet.

People in Dubai and Paraguay don’t talk like this. They just don’t.

It feels kinda weird, to see this gigantic country called the United States filled with people I don’t relate to anymore.

Even if you take me out of the equation, the term “American” in 2025 means nothing, and I mean nothing like the term used to mean in 1986.

This labeling stuff being inaccurate and useless is going to get even worse with AI. Terms like “human,” “dating,” “sex,” “work,” “universal basic income,” “art,” and many others are all going to radically change their meanings.

People will still say those words, but they won’t mean what they mean today.

The next 10-15 years are going to be a very wild ride for the English language.

Leave your comment below, but be sure to follow the Five Simple Rules.

17 Comments
  • Dandy Dude
    Posted at 01:49 pm, 11th February 2025

    Dick Cheney supported Kamala Harris

    What the hell?! That’s hilarious! I don’t pay attention to that stuff, but I’m old enough to remember the Bush years, and the notion of lefties clapping to Dick Cheney is absolutely hysterical, hahahahaha!
    On the “not relating to americans” topic: that’s the way I’ve felt my entire life among my countrymen (brazilians): don’t like soccer, don’t care for the music, hate the envy/anti-success culture, hate the lack of work ethic and commitment, etc. Also reminds me of Andrew Henderson explaining how he didn’t relate to ‘mericans and why he left.

  • Peter Young
    Posted at 03:15 pm, 11th February 2025

    It’s essentially modern-day McCarthyism.

    Back in the simpler times of the 40s and 50s, when “they” were mad at you, they just called you a “communist” and destroyed your life.

    Today, the attack surface area is much wider: Racist, misogynist, sex offender, convicted felon, Nazi, fascist, anti-science, anti-vaxxer.

    Which makes the whole thing with Tulsi Gabbard so hilarious. You could picture them back at HQ, racking their brains on how to smear her: “Well we can’t call her racist, can’t call her misogynist, and the machine we’ve built only targets men as sex offenders, what a conundrum! What do we do? Ooh, PUTIN! She has ties to Putin and Syria! Run with it folks!”.

    And I agree that it is sad. There are real people who actually are suffering from these things, but the media abuse is diluting these very real problems.

  • A Texan
    Posted at 11:17 pm, 11th February 2025

    Another irony is how the left claimed that the right would use government to imprison them, but look what the left has done with the IRS (Obama harassing conservative organizations), denied J6 prisoners their right to a speedy trial and cruel and unusual punishment, harassed Trump and Alex Jones and others (VDare) with lawfare, and such.

    I guess we will see what the result will be of using DOGE to uncover government waste and much of it things I could see 30 years ago and would even come up for discussion in the 1990s and 2000s. This was obvious to anyone who did a bit of reading at the time. Hell, I got Dod money to get an extra STEM degree while the feds were shutting down the smaller military bases across the country.

    As for racism, minorities are the most racist people in the US as we have learned. Funny those ghetto blacks were not welcoming Jose and Maria to take over their neighborhoods.

    The reality is that peak America was the 1960s when it was 90% White and mostly rural and even the minorities had solid values. Other than the racial BS which the feds did a disservice to America by inserting themselves into it instead of letting things take their natural course of working out, 1960s America was probably pretty good though before my time. I realize this not a popular opinion, but I see little evidence to the contrary.

  • Tom
    Posted at 11:50 pm, 11th February 2025

    As an Aussie living in Latin America, no matter the country I almost always get ‘que estado eres?’ (what state are you from?), to which I reply, ‘Oh no, soy canguro, soy Australiano!’ (I am a kangaroo, I’m Australian).
    It feels like I get treated much differently once I say this (everywhere, Argentina, Mexico, Paraguay), like somehow not being from North America I am more exotic or ‘not one of them’ or something!
    No offence meant by that, I love the USA & have many American Friends down here, just a strange observation!

  • Ryan Remencus
    Posted at 03:17 am, 12th February 2025

    Caleb, you mentioned 1986 in your article, perhaps you should have mentioned 1984! And doublethink and newspeak… from George Orwell’s classic…

    I also wonder if apps, their designed dopamine drip, and social media have each lowered the average attention span and the average ability to think critically in the West.

    Also, while Trump wont “fix it all” I am very heartened that he and Elon are exposing the extent of waste, fraud, and abuse in the US government.

    Most people like yourself who proclaim the death of the West talk about the deep state government – those non-elected employees that influence (control?) the US despite what flavor is “in charge” in the white house.

    What do you think about 65,000 estimated people who have taken the buyout to resign? Or the nearly 20,000 from USAIDwho are fighting not to be put on leave (only a few hundred remain)? This seems to contradict your assertion Trump love big government doesnt it?

    It might only stall the inevitable collapse, but its buying me (and others) time to position ourselves to leave the US.

    That is something at least. Dont you think that is good/useful?

  • Caleb Jones
    Posted at 08:29 am, 12th February 2025

    It’s essentially modern-day McCarthyism.

    Back in the simpler times of the 40s and 50s, when “they” were mad at you, they just called you a “communist” and destroyed your life.

    Today, the attack surface area is much wider: Racist, misogynist, sex offender, convicted felon, Nazi, fascist, anti-science, anti-vaxxer.

    Good analysis. I agree.

  • Caleb Jones
    Posted at 08:29 am, 12th February 2025

    I guess we will see what the result will be of using DOGE to uncover government waste

    Yes we will, and it’s one I already predicted, and I will be right.

    https://calebjones.com/elon-musk-and-doge-wont-make-any-net-cuts-in-government-spending/

  • Caleb Jones
    Posted at 08:31 am, 12th February 2025

    It feels like I get treated much differently once I say this (everywhere, Argentina, Mexico, Paraguay), like somehow not being from North America I am more exotic or ‘not one of them’ or something!

    Accurate. Latinos generally like Gringos, and in some countries more than others.

  • Caleb Jones
    Posted at 08:38 am, 12th February 2025

    I also wonder if apps, their designed dopamine drip, and social media have each lowered the average attention span and the average ability to think critically in the West.

    Yes, that is exactly what has occurred (among other causes).

    Also, while Trump wont “fix it all” I am very heartened that he and Elon are exposing the extent of waste, fraud, and abuse in the US government.

    You shouldn’t be.

    https://calebjones.com/elon-musk-and-doge-wont-make-any-net-cuts-in-government-spending/

    What do you think about 65,000 estimated people who have taken the buyout to resign? Or the nearly 20,000 from USAIDwho are fighting not to be put on leave (only a few hundred remain)? This seems to contradict your assertion Trump love big government doesnt it?

    You’re doing exactly what I said you guys would do.

    I said they will make a tiny dent in the size of government, celebrate like they won a huge victory, and the collapse will continue.

    Do you know how many federal employees there are?

    4.3 million.

    Plus around 6.8 million contractors.

    And you’re getting excited about 20,000 and maybe another 60,000?

    Do you see the problem?

    As I keep saying, wait 2-4 years, then look at the numbers, then look me in the eye and tell me Trump doesn’t like big government.

  • INTJ
    Posted at 11:59 am, 12th February 2025

    Hi Caleb. So you want to maximize your freedom and happiness, right? But you’re essentially shooting yourself in the foot by identifying yourself as an old guy and reading around, confused by the modern world. You don’t think you are, but you’re doing that classic old guy thing that we’ve all seen these curmudgeons do ever since we were kids. So I’m 12 years older than you.

    I grew up in Britain in the 70s and I absolutely don’t identify with any part of my history when I grew up. Except maybe I’ve got a playlist from 70s stuff and 70s cars gives me a bit of a smile.

    As I was growing up I slightly identified with the swinging 60s, which is not a big thing. I am who I am and not part of some popular culture movement. And so should you be. That means you have to take the good with the bad, as we always have to. So I feel less out of place because my playlist is pretty much the same as most 20-something-year-olds. Most 20 and 30-something-year-olds talk to me quite freely as though I’m the same generation, although with a slight awe because I think they’ve done quite a lot more than they have. I did a massive amount of world travelling from my late teens and certainly through my 20s. That was mainly with a camera sack on my back and just a few bucks in my pocket. Asia, much of Europe, Africa, and a little travelling in the US and Latin America. I’m mixed race and I’d be afraid to identify as British because that somehow applies to everyone. I feel some sort of outcast. So where are we going with this? You shift your frame of reference. You no longer have to hate your country, but see it as one of those parts of your five flags. Dubai and Paraguay are great. My business plans, which are being executed right now, have them as major bases. Hong Kong I’ve had to dirt drop. And that’s for very real operational reasons, not cut reactions.

    The story changes all the time and that’s part of living in the modern world. I guess my world view was really formed by reading science fiction and that science fiction was real science fiction relating to real world, not fantasy with dragons. So when I see an AI device, so I’d say I’m pretty much up to date. I’m probably the biggest user of AI, the biggest I know (and I work with a whole range of AI professionals and 30 somethings almost daily. AI has absolutely transformed what I do. The story here is to keep ahead of curve. I love a huge source of modern contemporary music. I don’t live in fantasy worlds of movies and television much. As people tell me, my real life is far better than, far more interesting than any movie. Don’t stick in the past or in fantasy Caleb – the real world is unfolding beautifully – enjoy it!

  • Dale
    Posted at 12:34 pm, 12th February 2025

    Good article Caleb

    It’s hilarious as a South African, viewing (on the periphery) the shit-show in the USA. For the last 20 years I’ve actively declined the ‘invitation’ to watch the local news…and believe me when I say, our government is a POS. There is no benefit to me ‘knowing’ what’s going on in my country and the world (most of it is lies anyway); it only lowers my morale, makes it harder to be happy and makes it harder to be neutral when interacting with other people I’m around. I don’t see the point, except perhaps to notice the anti-freedom headwinds that are only getting stronger all over the western world.

    I’m even more removed from American politics and I have get the terms (often and slowly) defined for me so I can at least think a rational thought about it and adequately converse about it without seeming stupid. But more and more I’m convinced that I just don’t care and can’t be bothered to have things ‘defined accurately’. This is even more pertinent now that the definitions are so broken. It’s just a massive distraction and destroys happiness.

    My primary focus is my long-term productivity and happiness.

  • Anonymous
    Posted at 09:38 am, 13th February 2025

    Nice article. Paraguay though is also America.

  • Caleb Jones
    Posted at 10:39 am, 13th February 2025

    Most 20 and 30-something-year-olds talk to me quite freely as though I’m the same generation, although with a slight awe because I think they’ve done quite a lot more than they have.

    Same here. I have sex with women in their mid-20s. Several of them. And I relate to them fine.

    So far, your point is inaccurate.

    Let’s see if you can provide other evidence that I “don’t understand the modern world” and that I’m acting like a “curmudgeon”…

    I did a massive amount of world travelling from my late teens and certainly through my 20s. That was mainly with a camera sack on my back and just a few bucks in my pocket. Asia, much of Europe, Africa, and a little travelling in the US and Latin America.

    So have I.

    Still not looking good for your point…

    So where are we going with this?

    I have no idea. All you’re doing is saying I’m doing this all wrong while doing everything you’ve done.

    You shift your frame of reference. You no longer have to hate your country, but see it as one of those parts of your five flags.

    I don’t hate the USA. I hate North Korea, but not the USA. I just A) don’t enjoy being there and B) get taxed when I go there for more than 35 days a year. Therefore, I don’t go there much.

    Dubai and Paraguay are great. My business plans, which are being executed right now, have them as major bases.

    You’re still agreeing with me…

    The story changes all the time and that’s part of living in the modern world. I guess my world view was really formed by reading science fiction and that science fiction was real science fiction relating to real world, not fantasy with dragons.

    I read mostly science fiction when I was young. Isaac Asimov, Arthur C. Clarke, Ben Bova, Jack Mckinney, Harlan Ellison, Robert Heinlein, etc.

    I only switched to fantasy later in life as an older adult.

    Still looking terrible for your point.

    So when I see an AI device, so I’d say I’m pretty much up to date. I’m probably the biggest user of AI, the biggest I know (and I work with a whole range of AI professionals and 30 somethings almost daily. AI has absolutely transformed what I do.

    Same here too. I use AI tools daily. It’s been a game changer for me.

    I don’t live in fantasy worlds of movies and television much.

    I don’t live in a fantasy world, I’m one of the most rationally objective people I know, and I don’t watch TV.

    The real world is unfolding beautifully – enjoy it!

    You don’t think I enjoy the world? Are you even aware of my lifestyle and personal life? Do you realize the number and quality of women I’ve had sex with in just the past 10 days? Do you know how exciting my international travel is for me?

    So congratulations, you’ve written the most useless comment I’ve seen on my blogs in several years. Stating an opinion and being unable to provide any point to back it up even after writing 4 big paragraphs. Well done.

  • Caleb Jones
    Posted at 10:46 am, 13th February 2025

    There is no benefit to me ‘knowing’ what’s going on in my country and the world (most of it is lies anyway); it only lowers my morale, makes it harder to be happy and makes it harder to be neutral when interacting with other people I’m around. I don’t see the point, except perhaps to notice the anti-freedom headwinds that are only getting stronger all over the western world.

    Haha, valid point.

    My primary focus is my long-term productivity and happiness.

    Perfect.

  • Caleb Jones
    Posted at 10:47 am, 13th February 2025

    Nice article. Paraguay though is also America.

    When I say “America” I mean the United States and that’s all. So do most people. We aren’t referring to the entire landmasses of the North American and South American continents when we say “America.”

    Weirdly irrational comments in this thread today.

    Must be something in the water.

  • INTJ
    Posted at 04:14 pm, 13th February 2025

    Hey Caleb

    Serves me right for dictating a message while getting on with my life!!! Let’s set this right. This wasn’t a PUA tirade. This was – “Caleb’s a brilliant guy and the Alpha 2.0 lifestyle is great plan” – let’s learn some stuff from him. Thats why I said stuff that shows I was aligned with your experience and values.

    So you do refer to yourself as an “old man” online and in real life (and even an old old man). Do you not know that? I wondered what value you get out of that. I see the benefits in it but I wondered if you saw disadvantages in positioning yourself like that? That’s more something for you to reflect on rather than for me to pontificate on. O

    I don’t think you are out of touch – I think you understand the modern world better than most. Its part of the value you bring people. You do root yourself very strongly in the cultures and values a particular part of your life (the 80s in your case) – most people do that – and that’s your right – I wondered whether you have examined or questioned the pros and cons of that. It works both ways. Because we almost all do it it’s interesting to explore.

    Your point about incorporating your birth country in you five flag – related to US tax laws – is a good response. And your comment about not enjoying the US also clarifies your position on that. I was not writing to say you don’t understand – I was writing to find out why. You explained. I live in a location close to where C.S. Lewis and Tolkien wrote and the positive side of things here are pretty similar to living in the Shire – so maintaining a toehold makes sense – but yes – I can see this could be ‘raised’ pretty easily – and soon.

    >> The comment about fantasy worlds of movies and television
    I agree that you are “rationally objective” – so science fiction of the type you’ve described gives us this wonderful toolkit for understanding the technological world – James Bond is pretty cool for identifying where to go – what to wear – Daniel Craig uses rizz that make you smile because you can recognise him doing things you know work in the real word. It would be really interesting to know if “Airwolf” influences your daily life in the same way. It doesn’t have to – but it would be fun to discover “Sh*t yes – there is this think . . .”

    >> Are you even aware of my lifestyle and personal life?
    Yes – mine isn’t so different. – that’s why its worth talking to you about this and finding out your views.

    >> 4 big paragraphs.
    Yeah – If I had more time I would have written you a shorter letter” – (credited to Winston Churchill)

    Perils of voice – 2 – text on the move . . .

  • Joe Zinke
    Posted at 02:21 pm, 14th February 2025

    Rudyard Lynch from Whatifalthist calls Wokeism “Emotional Communism”. I think that is an accurate description of the current state of Western Culture.

Post A Comment